---
title: Contractor or employee? Defining workers in the gig economy
description: Contractor or employee? Defining workers in the gig economy
---

[Insights and Updates ](https://www.hayesknight.com.au/insights-and-updates)

# [Contractor or employee? Defining workers in the gig economy](https://www.hayesknight.com.au/insights-and-updates/contractor-or-employee-defining-workers-in-the-gig-economy)

 Written by [Stephen Maze](https://www.hayesknight.com.au/insights-and-updates/author/stephen-maze) | Jan 5, 2019 9:00:15 PM

**A former Foodora Australia delivery rider, Joshua  
Klooger, recently won an unfair dismissal claim despite a service agreement  
that classified him as an independent contractor. We explore the implications  
of the case. **

Pivotal to  
the [Fair  
Work Commission’s decision](https://www.fwc.gov.au/documents/decisionssigned/html/2018fwc6836.htm) was the classification by Foodora of Mr  
Klooger as an independent contractor. The “Corporate Rider” was employed under  
a service agreement titled “Independent contractor agreement”. At the initial  
rate of $14 per hour and $5 per delivery, corporate riders would log into an  
app (the shifts app) which, at predetermined times each week, displayed  
available shifts. The shifts identified start and finish times and a specific  
geographical location where the delivery work would be undertaken. The riders  
could then decide what shifts they wanted. The riders undertaking shifts were  
provided with a Foodora branded insulated box, and other Foodora branded attire  
and equipment. Once the shift started, the riders would receive notifications  
through the app of an order to be picked up from a restaurant. Once the order  
had been collected, the rider would confirm the pick up, then the deliveries app  
would advise the delivery address.

In 2016, Mr  
Klooger’s friend and fellow Foodora delivery rider had his visa cancelled. As a  
result, Foodora suspended the friend’s access to the shifts and deliveries app.  
Instead, Mr Klooger gave his friend his access to the Foodora app allowing him  
to select and fulfil shifts. Over time, three other individuals did the same. Mr  
Klooger would reconcile his account, deduct tax and a further 1% for his  
involvement, then pay the substitutes. While the Foodora contract allowed for  
substituting, it required prior written consent. However, when Foodora became  
aware of the substitution scheme it took no steps to stop it and instead  
commended Mr Klooger for his “entrepreneurial initiative.”

The rates Foodora  
paid to riders and the way in which shifts were allocated changed over time. In  
July 2016, the hourly rate for new riders/drivers was reduced to $13 plus $3  
per delivery, and a $1 per delivery payment for Friday, Saturday and Sunday  
night work. Towards the end of 2016, Foodora removed the hourly rate for new  
riders completely, fixing a flat $10 per delivery payment. The flat rate was  
progressively reduced further and by February 2018, the rate for new delivery  
riders had dropped to $7 per delivery. In addition, a new “batching system” was  
put in place which established a fortnightly assessment process that ranked  
individual delivery riders and offered shifts according to rank. The highest  
ranked riders were offered shifts well before lower ranked riders.

When  
determining whether a worker is a contractor or an employee, the courts say “…  
the distinction between an employee and an independent contractor is rooted  
fundamentally in the difference between a person who serves his employer in  
his, the employer’s business, and a person who carries on a trade or business  
of his own.”

The factors  
identified by the commission in this case are helpful indicators:

**How work is fulfilled.** The commission determined that  
while the riders had the choice to accept the shifts, the shift start and  
finish times and geographical locations were fixed by Foodora. Despite the  
ability to self-select shifts, the commission saw that the “process for  
engagement is similar to a variety of electronic and web-based systems that are  
frequently used to advise, in particular, casual employees of available shifts  
that are offered.” While the system is not as prescriptive as naming particular  
employees, the commission saw the results as essentially similar.

**What the contract said.** While the Foodora service agreement  
attempts to establish a relationship of principal and contractor, the  
commission found that, “The service contract contains many provisions which are  
similar in form and substance to those that would ordinarily be found in an  
employment contract document.” These included clauses dealing with rostering  
and acceptance of jobs, the attire to be worn when on shift, the specific  
nature of the engagements to be undertaken including requirements that the  
contractor is to comply with all policies and practices of the principal.

**Who had control?** Foodora had “… considerable capacity to  
control the manner in which the applicant performed work.” The commission also  
noted that the batching system meant that to maintain a high ranking, riders  
had to perform a certain number of deliveries during a shift, work a minimum  
number of shifts in a week and work a number of Friday, Saturday and Sunday  
shifts. 

**Generating business. **In Foodora’s favour was the fact that  
it did not prevent its riders from working for other companies or delivery  
platforms. However, in this case the commission compared this ability to casual  
restaurant staff working for more than one restaurant.

**Is the contractor operating separate to the principal?** One of the aspects of many  
contractor versus employee cases is whether the individual holds themselves out  
to the public as a separate business in their own right – do they have their  
own place of business. In this case, Mr Klooger worked exclusively for Foodora.

**Supply of tools of trade. **Mr Klooger’s only investment as a  
contractor was his bicycle which he also used privately. An asset which the  
commission points out does not require a high degree of skill or training.

**Delegation of work.** One of the factors that determines whether  
someone is a contractor or employee is their capacity to delegate work to  
others. The substitution scheme operated by Mr Klooger was a significant factor  
in this case as he was delegating work. However, in this instance, the  
commission saw that the substitution scheme was a breach of Foodora’s own service  
agreement not evidence of delegation despite their eventual acceptance of the  
scheme by Foodora.

**Identifying as Foodora.** Riders had to identify as being  
from Foodora. Clause 4 of the service contract established an expectation  
riders dress in Foodora branded attire, and utilise equipment displaying the  
livery of the Foodora brand.

**Tax, leave, and remuneration**. As Foodora classified the riders  
as independent contractors no tax was deducted from payments made. Riders were  
not entitled to holiday or sick leave. When Foodora paid Mr Klooger, they would  
generate a recipient created invoice. Once Mr Klooger had reviewed the invoice  
and made any corrections, the invoice would be paid.

**Reputational damage. **If the riders did not perform to the  
standard expected by customers, it was Foodora that faced reputational damage  
not the riders.

While Mr Klooger  
won his case and was awarded $15,559, Foodora appointed voluntary  
administrators on 17 August 2018, well before this case came before the  
commission. The commission pursued the case on public importance grounds.

Foodora is  
by no means the first company to fall foul of the definition between contractor  
and employee; there are a litany of companies that have stepped over the  
definitional boundary but it is one of the first to test platform based work  
relationships in the gig economy.

However,  
not all gig economy businesses engaging with workers using a platform are at  
risk. In December 2017, an unfair dismissal claim against Uber was dismissed. Many  
of the factors evident in the Foodora case were not evident in Uber’s model.  
Interestingly, the commission noted that current laws that determine work for  
wages and the nature of employment relationships “… developed and evolved at a  
time before the new “gig” or “sharing” economy. It may be that these notions  
are outmoded in some senses and are no longer reflective of our current  
economic circumstances. These notions take little or no account of revenue  
generation and revenue sharing as between participants, relative bargaining  
power, or the extent to which parties are captive of each other, in the sense  
of possessing realistic alternative pursuits or engaging in competition.  
Perhaps the law of employment will evolve to catch pace with the evolving  
nature of the digital economy.”

Pre-empting  
the commission’s warning on the gig economy was the [2017  
Senate report ](https://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Education_and_Employment/AvoidanceofFairWork/Report) that asked  
whether the gig economy is “hyper flexibility or sham contracting.” In addition  
to exploring the model of organisations like Deliveroo, the Senate committee  
demonstrated how apps like AirTasker are being used by businesses for ongoing  
roles without the burden of employment. The fee Airtasker takes is charged only  
to the worker. Posters deposit payment into an account managed by the company,  
and Airtasker then releases 85% of that money to the worker, once the job  
poster declares the work to be complete.

## What to do if you engage contractors

If you engage  
contractors, it is essential to get the facts of the relationship right.  
Business owners need to take a proactive approach to reviewing arrangements to  
ensure that the business is not exposed to material liabilities. Key factors  
include:

- Whether the work involves a  
  particular profession or skill set.
- The level of control the contractor  
  has over how the contract is executed.
- The ability of the contractor to  
  delegate work to another person.
- Whether the contractor supplies his  
  own tools or equipment.
- Whether the contractor has his own  
  place of business.
- The contractor’s ability to generate  
  goodwill or saleable assets during the course of the contract.
- How the contractor is paid (for  
  hours worked or a result).
- The level of risk the contractor  
  bears.
- Whether the contractor is  
  independent or in reality, simply 'part and parcel' of the organisation they  
  contract to.

No single  
factor is determinative; it is the weight of evidence, on balance, across all  
of the factors.

## The implications of misclassifying a worker

The  
implications of misclassifying a worker go well beyond industrial relations. If  
a business misclassifies an employee, it impacts on superannuation guarantee  
(SG), PAYG withholding, workers compensation, and payroll tax. These  
entitlements will often need to be met even if the misclassification was a  
genuine mistake.

For SG  
obligations, there is no real time limit on the recovery of outstanding  
obligations. However, the ATO will generally only go back 5 years unless the  
individual employee can prove an entitlement beyond this point. Remember that  
employers that fail to make their superannuation guarantee payments on time don’t  
just pay the outstanding superannuation but are subject to the SG charge (SGC)  
and lodge a [Superannuation Guarantee Statement](http://www.ato.gov.au/content/downloads/nat2125.pdf). SGC is made up of:

- The employee’s  
  superannuation guarantee shortfall amount;
- Interest of 10% per annum;  
  and
- An administration fee of $20  
  for each employee with a shortfall per quarter. 

Unlike  
normal superannuation guarantee contributions, SGC amounts are not deductible  
to the employer, even when the liability has been satisfied.

Getting it wrong can be a very costly exercise particularly if the error is evident over a number of years.

**If you are uncertain about the classification of existing or future contract employees, give [Stephen Maze](https://www.hayesknight.com.au/team/stephen-maze/) a call on +61 2 9221 6666 or drop him a line.**

[View full post](https://www.hayesknight.com.au/insights-and-updates/contractor-or-employee-defining-workers-in-the-gig-economy)

```json
{
  "@context" : "http://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Stephen Maze"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-01-04T22:06:58.944Z",
  "datePublished" : "2019-01-05T21:00:15Z",
  "headline" : "Contractor or employee? Defining workers in the gig economy",
  "image" : {
    "@type" : "ImageObject",
    "height" : 693,
    "url" : "https://cdn2.hubspot.net/hubfs/7212131/bimage-deliveroo-1024x693.jpg",
    "width" : 1024
  },
  "mainEntityOfPage" : "https://www.hayesknight.com.au/insights-and-updates/contractor-or-employee-defining-workers-in-the-gig-economy",
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "height" : 60,
      "url" : "/hs/hsstatic/content_shared_assets/static-1.4092/img/default-amp-logo.png",
      "width" : 60
    },
    "name" : "The latest insights"
  }
}
```